In “Invitation to Debate” no X, president asked followers to ask ChatgPT if judges can participate in hearings held during award -winning denunciations
Former President Jair Bolsonaro (PL) used the social network X (former Twitter) to suggest that his followers question the AI (artificial intelligence) about the possibility of judges participating in award-winning allegations. The initiative seems to refer to the performance of the Supreme Court Minister Alexandre de Moraes in the denunciation of Lieutenant Colonel Mauro Cid, former Assistant of Orders of Bolsonaro.
Bolsonaro wondered if a judge could participate “Of the hearings held during the award -winning denunciation”. The responses of OpenAi’s chatgpt claim that the magistrates are limited to “The approval of the agreement, verifying if it was made voluntarily and legal.” Other tools stress that, although the judge does not have the power of intervention, it must approve the agreement.
Read the
In consultation with AI tools, the Poder360 obtained the following answers:
- ChatGPT: “No, the judge cannot participate in the hearings held during the award -winning denunciation. The negotiation and conclusion phase of the agreement occurs between the employee and the prosecutor (or the police authority, in some cases). The judge only intervenes after the agreement is signed, to approve it, ensuring that it was made voluntarily and within the legality ”;
- Deepseek: “In Brazil, the judge does not participate directly in the initial negotiations of the award -winning denunciation, which are conducted by the Public Prosecution Service and the defense. However, he approves the agreement, ensuring that he is within the law and that the whistleblower acted voluntarily. After the approval, the judge may preside over the testimony hearings, ensuring that legal formalities are fulfilled. In short, the judge acts mainly on approval and hearings, but not in the initial negotiations ”;
- Gemini: “In Brazil, the judge does not participate in the negotiations of the award -winning plea agreement, which are conducted between the prosecutor or the Federal Police and the employee. However, the judge may participate in the hearings held during the award -winning denunciation in some specific situations ”;
- Meta ai: “The judge cannot participate in the award -winning denunciation hearings. He only approves the agreement after verifying if the legal requirements were met, maintaining his impartiality ”.
Cid delation
Minister Alexandre de Moraes became public on Wednesday (19.FEV.2025) the award of Lieutenant Colonel Mauro Cid with the Federal Police and the STF. In one of the documents, the magistrate establishes as benefit the “Judicial forgiveness” your a “Penalty deprivation of liberty” less than 2 years for the newly reported.
Among the advantages are also the restitution of the assets seized from the employee and the promise of security to ICD and his family. The granting of benefits is subject to proof of the effectiveness of the collaboration.
