Minister Luiz Fux was the only one in the first class to welcome the second preliminary presented in relation to the Supreme Court’s competence to judge the case
The second preliminary presented concerns the competence of the first class in judging the accused. “This story has already been pacified in 1,494 actions. It is not a new matter,” the rapporteur maintained. “I take the opportunity to undo narrative narrative,” he said, “that the STF would be condemning old ladies with the Bible in hand, which would be walking around the square of the three powers. Nothing more liar than that,” he said.
Dino states that regimental change did not have his participation
The minister stated that in 2023 he was not in the regimental change to define that the STF classes would be responsible for criminal trials and the formation of the two groups. “In this chair there was a possibility of a vacancy to be provided by any other fellow of the Court. There was no casual decision of my participation,” he said. At the time, Dino was Minister of Justice of the Government of. “The competence of the 1st class should be affirmed for the trial of former President Bolsonaro and members of the previous government.
Fux diverges from the rapporteur and welcomes the preliminary
“Worse than the judge who does not know right, he is the incoherent judge,” said the minister, saying that the matter (competence of the STF class) is not that pacified. The minister recalled that this month voted on the matter, and was overcome. For him, the issue of the number of actions that have already been judged, as Moraes argued, does not prevent the issue from debated again. “I leave excuse to maintain my coherence I had last week,” he said, diverging from the rapporteur and voting in favor of the preliminary.
Cármen Lúcia also vote to recognize the competence of the 1st class
The minister stated in her vote that the Supreme Court defined the current standard that allows the trial to occur in the 1st class. “It’s the STF talking,” he said.
Zanin accompanies Moraes and preliminary about competence is rejected
Zanin, the chairman of the class, accompanied the rapporteur for rejection of the preliminary, also citing the “numerous judgments” that positioned himself in favor of the competence of the Court and the classes. The minister asked Fux “apologies”, saying that he would also have to maintain his consistency on the subject.
*With information from Estadão Content
Posted by Fernando Dias
