The minister, of the (Supreme Federal Court), granted house arrest, using an electronic anklet, to the hairdresser, who, after request of the Attorney General, later this Friday (28).
Deborah, 39, had been detained in closed regime for two years. Boconists use her case on amnesty requests to the accused of January 8 and speak of disproportionate justice.
Earlier this week, Minister Luiz Fux paralyzed her judgment, which takes place in the virtual plenary. Moraes had voted for a 14 -year sentence, 12 years and 6 months in closed regime.
Deborah became a defendant, accused by the Attorney General’s Office of the crimes of armed criminal association, attempted violent abolition of the Democratic Rule of Law, attempted coup and damage qualified by violence and serious threat against the heritage of the Union.
Now Gonet argued that the request for view – time for process analysis – would make the concession of reasonable home.
In the decision, Moraes states that the postponement of the termination of the trial made it necessary to analyze the situation of deprivation of Deborah.
According to the minister, if the trial had been terminated with the application of the sanctions proposed in his vote, rapporteur of the case, the hairdresser would be sentenced to 14 years in prison.
“There is, therefore, the need for compatibility between the ‘right to freedom’ and the ‘application of criminal law’, with the adequacy of the necessary, reasonable and adequate restrictions on freedom to come and go and the legal and procedural requirements,” he said.
Thus, he replaced the pre-trial detention with home, with the use of electronic anklet, prohibition of use of social networks, communicating with the others involved in the scammer acts of January 8, 2023, to give interviews to any communication vehicle or receiving visits, except for her lawyers with power of attorney in the case.
Deborah’s case has had a lot of repercussion, especially after Fux’s initiative. Amid the analysis of the PGR complaint about the coup plot, the minister commented on the case, spoke of concern about the issue of the dosimetry of the penalties imposed by the court to the defendants of January 8, 2023, that is, how long each accused may face if he is convicted.
This Friday, at an event at UERJ (State University of Rio de Janeiro), the president of, said that in cases such as Deborah, Brazilians range from “indignation to penalty”.
“Brazil has the characteristic that, when the episodes happen, people have a deep indignation. And then, as time goes by, they get sorry. We went from indignation to penalty,” said Barroso.
