Cases such as do Monthly and the current case against the former president Jair Bolsonaro (PL) should be processed in first instance courts and not in the STF (Federal Supreme Court)evaluates FGV Director Direct São Paulo, Oscar Vilhenain an interview with CNN 360°this Thursday (3).
“The court is not prepared for this, busy a huge time, the Supreme has to gather evidence. It is a judgment clearly should be up to the first instance,” said Oscar Vilhena, who is a member of the committee of OAB-SP (Brazilian Bar Association of São Paulo) that studies proposals for judiciary reform.
According to the teacher, the case of the monthly, which involved the transfer of money to have support in Congress, took years to be tried in the Supreme Court. The situation made the court change the analysis of the criminal cases of the plenary to the classes – first and second.
Still, according to Vilhena, criminal cases should be dealt with in other courts. However, he recognizes that the judgment of politicians and the extent of the forum were provided for in the Constitution.
“Now it is important that they are in classes, he [o Supremo] Make your judgment. But see, the model of the Constitution is not good, “he said, saying that it would not be appropriate to transfer the judgment of the former president at this time.
Judiciary Reform
. The commission is composed of former STF ministers, former Justice Ministers and academic jurists. According to the OAB-SP, the proposals for reforms will be sent to Congress and the judiciary in 2026.
Currently, the group has defined five axes for discussion: slowness, integrity, access to justice, stability and the Federal Supreme Court.
In addition to Oscar Vilhena, they are part of the Commission: the Retired Ministers of STF Ellen Gracie and Cezar Peluso; Former Justice Ministers Miguel Reale Jr. (Fernando Henrique Cardoso government) and José Eduardo Cardozo (Dilma Rousseff Management); jurists Alessandra Benedito and Maria Tereza Sadek; and former presidents of the national OAB, Cezar Britto, and São Paulo sectional, Patricia Vanzolini.
