Ricardo Araújo Pereira compared to Mário Machado by the lawyer of the Anjos

In the last hearing of the trial Angels vs. Joana Marques, the singers’ lawyer compared Ricardo Araújo Pereira’s testimony to that of Neonazi Mário Machado, in the case of which she was condemned, by discrimination and incitement to hatred and violence to left women.

The fourth and audience of the Judgment that opposes angels and Joana Marques.

A AGREEMENT OF THE “ANGELS” insisted that Joana Marques has to be sentenced to compensate the pair at 1,118,000 euros for moral and heritage damage, by a humor video published in 2022, on Instagram.

The duo also wants Joana Marques to erase the video and publicly portray themselves to have produced and spread it.

In turn, the defense of the humorist fought for acquittal.

Ricardo Araújo Pereira Compared to Mário Machado

At one point, the lawyer of the angels made at the third session of the trial last week, comparing it to arguments that Mário Machado usedin the case of which he was sentenced to two years of 10 months in effect, due to discrimination and incitement to hatred and violence to leftist women.

The lawyer of the “angels”, Natália Luísstarted by accusing Ricardo Araújo Pereira de presumptionas to the question of the limits of mood.

Then he said that Joana Marques’ colleague It is not an “light lighthouse”: “He is not the light and we are not in the darkness. He entered here to say that humor has no limits, that [os humoristas] They can do everything. ”

Then compared the humorist to the non -humorist Mário Machado.

“One of Mario Machado’s arguments in his defense was precisely this, which was playing. We cannot allow ourselves to ourselves. Making this reflection is important, it is very important, ”he said, quoted by.

“Freedom of expression is not an absolute right”finished.

Remember that Mário Machado was convicted of publications on the social network X against leftist women who aimed in particular the teacher and former director of the Socialist Alternative Movement (MAS), Renata Cambra.

Concerned in this process were messages published on the social network, attributed to Mário Machado and Ricardo Pais – Also condemned in this process – in which these from the leftist parties, and which they aimed in particular Renata Cambra.

Humorist Joana Marques, in turn, published on Instagram a montage, which intersperses excerpts from Nelson and Sérgio Rosado singing the national anthem At a MotoGP test in Portimão, in April 2022, with derogatory reactions taken from the “idols” program.

Fourth and last session

In the final allegations of the trial, Natália Luís maintained that Joana Marques committed “something illicit” by manipulating the original transmission of acting and disintegrating society and stressed that the humorist could not be aware that such would generate negative reactions if she did not know that she did not drop a match in a hay burden will set a fire.

The rose brothers’ lawyer considers that Sérgio and Nelson were targets of bullying and cyberbullying because of this publication by Joana Marques.

“Bullying and cyberbullying only exists with children? No. This is a scourge. It is harmful to distort content and realities. And it’s dangerous in a rule of law. Joana wanted to convince the masses of a reality that knows it’s not true,” he said.

In the answer, the comedian’s defender pointed out that he “did not introduce changes to accentuate failures” of the acting, caused by the original transmission – including the replacement of “egregious” by “egregijos” – and that negative reactions had already generated reactions already generated reactions online.

Nuno splashes He added that the thesis of the “angels” would imply that “all humorists” would have to predict whether something they produce is likely to cause damage, in a context in which “It is impossible to consider a hypothesis in which content does not generate a single negative reaction”.

In the morning, Pedro Taborda, better known for Tatankaspoke at the trial, at the request of the angels. The singer appeared in the montage made by Joana Marques, alongside the humorist, since they were colleagues in the program “Idols”.

“Anyone with two forehead fingers will realize that the images were humorous”he said in court, lamenting to be there.

Also in the morning, Joana Marques had the opportunity to speak. He says he never thought that “this work was so scrutinated,” lamenting after he would rather see another work of his “more complex”. The audience laughed.

“[O vídeo] It was to laugh. Obviously I had no other intention. The intention is equal to everything I do, intention to make laugh (…) I found it unusual (…) and the mood starts from there. I considered caricatus, at the time I was in the idols and remembered to gather the two universes, ”he said, quoted by.

The sentence of the Central Civil Court of Lisbon will be communicated in writing to the parties, on an unknown date. Given that summer judicial holidays start on July 16, it is not expected to occur before September.