For PL deputies, the divergence of the STF minister in the Bolsonaro trial is a reason for “pride”
Opposition deputies (PL-RS), (PL-CE) and (MDB-RJ) celebrated, from the Supreme Court (STF), in conversation with journalists on Wednesday (10.Set.2025).
Fernandes said the minister the “filled with pride ” and is “Honoring the toga.” He also stated that he “Bring hope“Fux for incompetence of the 1st Panel of the Supreme Court. For the minister, the defendants have no prerogative of forum to be tried by the Court.
Fernandes also stated to expect the process to go to the first instance or to the court plenary. “Other ministers will be entitled to express their vote without curtailing the freedom of expression of the STF ministers themselves ”these.
Zucco stated that the minister’s arguments make room for requests for review and annulment by the defenses. According to the deputy, this will cause “Great legal insecurity”. The opposition leader also stated that the 1st class of the Supreme Court is discussing an issue that “It is not legal ”but “policy“.
Otoni agreed with Zucco: “The minister’s vote fills us with hope. It will not change the decision of the 1st class, because we are facing a political decision, not only a technical, legal decision.”
The deputies still say hoping that Fux asks for a view at the end of reading his vote. “If he does not ask, he opens a great precedent for this decision of the 1st class to be questioned”, said Otoni.
The minister has already signaled at the session of this Wednesday (10.Set) who will not ask for a view.
In social networks, opposition congressmen praised Fux:
Read more about the trial:
Bolsonaro’s trial
The 1st class of judges the former president (PL) and 7 more defendants for attempted coup d’état. The Supreme has heard the oral support of all defendants’ defenses. Now they will be the ministers to vote. On Tuesday (9.Set), Minister Flávio Dino Minister Alexandre de Moraes and voted for.
A It is expected that the process will be completed by Friday (12.set), with the discussion about the dosimetry of the penalties.
Integrate the 1st class of the STF:
- Alexandre de Moraesrapporteur of the action;
- Flávio Dino;
- Cristiano ZaninPresident of the 1st Class;
- Cármen Lúcia;
- Luiz Fux.
In addition to Bolsonaro, they are defendants:
- Alexandre Ramagem, and ;
- Almir Garnierformer commander of the Navy;
- Anderson Torresformer Minister of Justice;
- Augusto Helenoformer minister of institutional security;
- Mauro Cidex-assistant of presidency orders;
- Paulo Sérgio Nogueiraformer defense minister;
- Walter Braga Netto, of the Civil House.
The nucleus 1 of the coup attempt for the to commit 5 crimes: armed criminal organization and attempts to abolish the democratic rule of law and coup d’état, as well as qualified damage and deterioration of listed assets.
If Bolsonaro is sentenced, the minimum penalty is 12 years in prison. The maxim. If there is a conviction, the ministers will define the penalty individually, considering the participation of each defendant. The penalties determined against Jair Bolsonaro and the other 7 accused, however, will only be met after the final judgment, when there is no more possibility of appeal.
As a former president, if convicted in res judicata, Bolsonaro should be arrested in a special room in Papuda, federal prison in Brasilia, or at the PF (Federal Police) Superintendence in the federal capital.
